Dude, there are alot of negative people in this thread!
Jboraski, the design looks ok... alright. Don't worry about that so much. The problem you stated originally was getting the site to fit into every browser. They were right earlier when someone told you to resize to 764 pixels. 800 will still get you scroll bars, but 764 should get it just right. I measured your current design and I got 970 pixels. Thats to large. Bring it down to 764 and you'll be ok. As far as giving up, don't listen to the negative people that are posting hear. I am ashamed to say that we are all members of Web Pro World. This is the first thread that I have read that has total negativity. As you post more, you'll find out who to listen to. People like Webnauts and BJ are excellent at what they do and take great pride in their posts. I'm sorry to see they haven't posted to you yet. Maybe they took the day off.
One final note though. Yes get off of Front Page. Use Dreamweaver. I'm not saying it's the end all be all, but it is the industry standard.
We all started off somewhere in web design. I started back in 1996 and I still learn every day of the week. There is always going to be something new to learn. This is a ever eveolving industry and if you stop learning new thing then and only then should you think about quitting. Keep learning and keep posting your problems and there are plenty of people that will try and help. Just weed out the negativity.
DaveBarnes is also a good poster, but I agree that he could have been a little more tackful with what he was trying to tell you. You'll see that he posts here a bit to.
Good Luck - hope to see more posts from you