Unique/quirky or terrible? Does my site stand out?

[Plecpicker]

Good points!
I need to work on the search function and put in checks so "thumb picks" is translated as "thumb pick".
Bad item descriptions are definitely a factor too.

Good idea for metal thumb and finger picks.
Metal finger picks are generally better so I'll them put them on the shopping list.

[Plecpicker]

I've changed the colour scheme a fair amount since my last post.

Would really appreciate some honest feedback/advice.

Thank you all for the kind responses

[deepsand]

This purely subjective, of course, but overall it's a bit too dark for my liking.

[Plecpicker]

Playing around with some new designs, will post the results.
Plan to keep the spooky look. Dark can be friendly if done correctly, some new graphics should improve that.
Thanks for the crit

[mjtaylor]

It doesn't feel as though it has changed appreciably since I first looked; perhaps a little lighter?

[Plecpicker]

Standardised all fonts except the menu to Georgia (I hope)
and
Played around with the colour codes.

The moon bat has flown away and a been replaced with a less pixel heavy cousin.

That's about it really for now.
It's been suggested I learn to use vector images.
Anyone know a good starting point?
I'm clueless.

[deepsand]

It dawns on me what's been bothering me re. the colors - it's the green and orange. That's combination that has always clashed for me. Not sure how it works for others.

[Plecpicker]

I've swapped the orange at the top for plain white text.
Thanks for pointing that out deepsand.

The add to cart buttons definitely look off.
Any suggestions?

Maybe the bluey/green used on this forum would be a nice blend?

[deepsand]

There's still a good bit of orange in the pick images.

Perhaps replacing the green between the horizon and the black upper sky with a graded gray or powder blue might do.

[Plecpicker]

I'm still debating if I should lose the green.
Updated the add to cart for the small items to compare against the bigger items.

Which one you do you prefer?
Thanks for the advice.