Of course, they can. I must have been thinking of likes and how they show up on my Facebook profile.
It *is* just another factor, but as Clay points out, if all other things are equal, social factors can make the difference. Social signals are a factor, and many SEOs I respect predict the SEO value of social shares will increase.
SEO Friendly Premium Web Directory - Submit Now| Need to write a love letter to Google? I'm an SEO Copywriter who knows Search Smart DesignŽ. | Travel Gypsy in Key West.