Kgun, with respect you're both on the wrong forum I think. I think the James Randi forums would be more suitable.
and with regards to seo consultants that "dont seem to know what they are talking about" - how would you know, as neither of you are SEOs?
I would define a professional SEO as somebody making a living at ranking client (or their own) sites, do either of you 2 fit that category? ..I do.
one of my clients sites turns over 350k GBP per month, it was about half that when I took it over 3 years ago. clearly I have no clue
for my part I am sceptical of people who hypothesise until the cows come home but can't rank for toffee.