Quote:
Originally Posted by brentjlaf
1. FLASH: I personally don't like the flash but the owners seen some other sites and wanted it.
|
Ok, fair enough, but be careful about what site owners say they want; You as the professional know best.
Quote:
Originally Posted by brentjlaf
2. The fixed height is something else the owners wanted. They wanted somethings that can all be seen on a page with no scrolling.
|
The same comment as above, with the addition of, if the user wants to increase the text size with their browser, what happens to the layout? HINT: the text bleeds out of the box onto the dark blue background graphic and becomes difficult to decipher.
I learned when doing usability testing on an intranet I was redesigning that many people inadvertently resize their text on IE with the mouse scroll-wheel and don't know that they can change it back. This was much more common, than you might think, especially with office workers. Perhaps you can convince them that a longer page height could benefit them by providing more breathing room on the page, and making it more flexible. Pixel perfect font sizing and placement is fine for print, but on a Web page it isn't realistic nor do I think it is even desirable.
Quote:
Originally Posted by brentjlaf
3. Dream. Believe. Realize. is on all the marketing material.
|
Fair enough, but I was saying that they linked nowhere. I see you removed the links....
Quote:
Originally Posted by brentjlaf
4. Resort. Residential. Commercial. - Are you suggesting links to separate pages explaining the 3?
|
Well, since they have the same approximate typographic treatment as the main navigation, users MAY think that they would be links as well. Would it be so bad to make them link to a featured portfolio project in each of those areas? Just a suggestion.
Quote:
Originally Posted by brentjlaf
5. The 'read more' link - Changed
|
Cool. Much better, I think.
Quote:
Originally Posted by brentjlaf
6. HOME NEWS and CONTACT links in the main nav and the footer - Will be fixing.
|
If you take the suggestion of making the page expand vertically, it may not be a bad idea to put them back in the footer; but keep them consistent with the main nav on top.
Quote:
Originally Posted by brentjlaf
7. Financial - The owner wanted to add this section and hasn't provided the content for it yet.
|
Fair enough.
Quote:
Originally Posted by brentjlaf
8. Hotels Surprise Page - It isn't the only one, one the developments page if you click any of the CURRENT developments they too are formatted in this way.
|
Yes, I noticed this after my original post, however, I still think it is a bad idea to break consistency this way, especially since all other pages maintain a different layout. Curious: why do the 'current developments' have the same treatment as the HOTELS but the 'completed developments' portfolio has the same treatment as the HOME page and all the rest?
I also have the same problem with the scrolling area within a page as mentioned by DaveBarnes above. I am afraid that many people would miss that they can scroll it. It also causes a problem when using a mouse wheel because if the mouse is over the scrolling area, it will scroll, but if it's over anything else on the page, the whole page will scroll.
This is often annoying to users and frustrating if they have to keep moving the mouse to read all the content. Again, I would suggest breaking the fixed height layout, but if you must maintain it, maybe a subnavigation in the left pane so that people can click through to see each project.
Rethinking your whole layout/architecture may not be a bad idea either. There is an awful lot of clicking going on with very little content; perhaps it could be redesigned to combine some of the links; home, about, and news come to mind as an 'about us' page. you get the point...
Finally, I want to say again that your images and graphic treatment are gorgeous. Having said that, since you are maintaining a fixed-height page, I don't know if I would use up 40% of vertical and 33% of the horizontal space with design elements as opposed to content.
Quote:
Originally Posted by brentjlaf
thanks for your comments.
|
My pleasure; I am here to help.
Good luck.