The site is at that point where commentary is not going to tell you much. Information requires interaction testing, with users, for desirability, information, and usability.
For a post in a forum like this, set up a nonactive dummy account. Set up a persona the reviewer can choose to assume. A business man with definite tasks will look at a site differently from a newlywed couple. Have reviewer find lodging which is right for a specific context (a specific tour route, sales calls or business negotiations at specific locations). And then go through the entire process from browsing to ordering.
Then you may have a chance at getting some crumbs of information. Otherwise you'll get "the site looks good" and "make the logo bigger."
Sites posting for review, it seems, assume much. Reviewers don't really go through the entire site as users would, so don't uncover nearly all of what a site really needs. If you have cross browser issues, or a dead link, a review can really help out. Not so interaction or business issues.
|