Design Tools Question

[pimil]

Hi, when you create original graphics, logos etc do you typically use a tablet (something like Wacom's Intuos2) or the mouse? I have created graphics and a few logos with Photoshop, Fireworks, and Freehand, but I have only used the mouse. I am an artist that typically draws and paints "offline" so to speak, but I am starting to tinker more and more with computer graphics. I'm thinking about getting something like an Intuos tablet and would like some recommendations from the forum. Thanks in advance.

[nickfoster]

Hi, Nice Site!

I have always used a mouse for my designs, although I don't have much of an argument for or against either method I would still be interested in trying out other methods such the Intuos tablet. This method may suit you more as your used to the "Offline" method.

Cheers
Nick Foster

[ecobo]

I use only Illustrator to make logos since a logo MUST be in some vector format (ai, eps, cdr etc.). I don't use a tablet - the mouse is enough for me. A tablet is needed when you create or manipulate raster images in Photoshop or any other raster processor.

[eightfifteen]

I have tried the tablets, but I just can't get used to them, but I know people who would rather lose a leg than give up their tablet. I have used the mouse for so long, and in such detailed work, that I would be lost if I had to use a tablet now. If I forced myself, I'm sure I could get used to it, and then find it invaluable in Photoshop.

If you are a Painter user, it is almost a must, but if you use Illustrator, not much use for a tablet.

[voodooboy]

I always start on paper, create several samples, scan them, then go into Illustrator or Freehand and recreate using the mouse.

I use a tablet when dealing with applications like Painter or Photoshop and am manipulating photos.

[pimil]

Hi, thanks for the replies! Ghstdrgns, I see where many of the professional design houses such as Phinney Bischoff http://www.pbdh.com start on paper, scan it it and manipulate it in Adobe Illus.. I have looked into Streamline, but have also read that Adobe may discontinue producing it. Have you used Streamline? If so, how did/does it work for you? Ecobo, if I produce logos in Photoshop, but save them as an .EPS, will they then be converted to vector thus enabling problem free resizing? Thanks guys!

[eightfifteen]

Yes, Adobe has pulled the plug on Streamline. It works OK if you have a relatively simple design, and a good scan of it. Anything too complicated, and it gets confused. It can create a cool "Streamlined" effect if that particular look is what you are after.

[scenesone]

trust me, JUST GET ONE!! these guys don't know what they're talking about...

[grease]

I highly recommend a Waccom, if not for the creative freedom, then definitely for your wrist! It will take a week to get the hang of it, but once you got it, you REALLY got it. You will see your productivity soar. The only downside is the mouse scroll button - but you will get used to doing a quick flick motion that works just as well.

I have a background in portrait drawing, and the Waccom pen is the closest thing I could find to a true pencil motion.

I always start on paper first for concepts- the screen is certain to stunt your creativity. (Trust me, you can tell the difference)

Grease

[pimil]

Thanks everyone for the helpful feedback!