Kelly,
You wrote: "our Contact Us page is terrible and my boss wants me to "fix it" ASAP!!"
It is not terrible, as I wrote yesterday.
Something else (not technical) is going on if "ASAP" is being thrown about. Your boss has a hidden agenda here. For example, sales are down so blame it on the contact us page.
Your 800 phone number is very obvious on the page. If I--as a student or parent--were confused, I would just call. Are your phone procedures working correctly?
One of your competitors has this contact page:
http://www.ifsa-butler.org/contact/index.html which does not seem any "better" to me.
As a parent whose daughter just started her semester abroad, I am somewhat attuned to what your website offers. As a parent, I only had 2 questions about study abroad: how much more money will it cost? and you will get Columbia points for this, right? Every other question was really unimportant.
I still don't like the BBB logo on the About Us page. Butler does not have anything similar. I just don't see "academia" and BBB as fitting together. In fact, the BBB logo makes me think that you are some kind of carpet cleaning company that also does study abroad.
,dave