Your attributes are "different", "unique", "outside the box" and "creative". The first 3 attributes are having the same message. So you have 2 prongs: "different" and "creative". Is the other logo below the older one? Which one do you think is more "creative"?
I think the one below. It includes more of each attribute than the black and white one.
Good luck!

__________________
Assistant to Bill Haig. For a complete Credibility Based Logo Design sm review visit http://www.powerlogos.com and access Bill Haigs no cost logo evaluation form on the home page.