If you include a field on your form with a name of either 'Email' or 'email', and the person filling out your form enters something in that field that looks like it might be a valid Email address, then the forms-to-email program will set the 'Reply-To' header in the email that is sent to you to the value filled in by the user. Otherwise, yoou will get
www@server1194.dnslive.net in the reply.
In the first form it's <input name="emailaddy" type="text" id="emailaddy">
In the second form it's <input name="email" type="text" id="email">
So change the first form from emailaddy to email
Also, you may want to make that a required field. If the user doesn't put an address in there, then you get
www@server1194.dnslive.net.
If it's not clear, I'll try to re-explain it. Good luck!