I didn't particularly like either of the choices in the poll, but I opted for "stuck businessman", simply because I think John is very much a businessman.
I probably read 30 or 40 posts here, for every one I make, since I signed up here to learn. (I certainly don't know enough about
SEO to teach anyone, yet)
By lurking, I've managed to learn a bit about many of the regulars here...who has a sense of humor, who can back up their opinions with an intelligent explanation, and perhaps most importantly, who is always willing to offer sound advice.
I don't recall any posts in the "Please Review My Site" section, that said, "be gentle. I have a fragile ego." When we ask for advice or analysis, it is only reasonable to hope that we will get just that...no sugar-coating, no phony stroking of ego, just impressions and advice.
John is one (and there are several others here) that gives honest analysis, backed up with solid "best practice". If there are any others here that are more knowledgeable in
SEO, I have failed to notice it.
I suppose we should be grateful that he's of Greek descent.
If he were French, he'd probably be insufferably arrogant!
Edit: By the way, I happen to think that his avatar is an actual photo of him!