Hello Ripken.

One area of potential improvement I see is your code.

1. Clean up long links
2. Switch to a DIV based design vs tables
3. Try a template which prioritizes the content - so it appears above the menu in your code (when you click view source).
4. Make any relevant updates to title & description tags at this time.

It's a significant recoding project, but I think it will pay off in terms of indexing.

Do you currently have any type of content management system? If not, try MODx - it's a bit cumbersome to use at first, but extremely reliable and flexible.