SEO Analysis 1 :
Your website is not operating in a HIGHLY COMPETITIVE SECTOR like gaming, software, web design and
seo etc etc. Therefore your chances of getting penalised are less as compared to other sectors.
However you should ensure that you never used any of these techniques listed at :
Avoid these SEO Techniques SEO HAWK ( Mostly On-page)
In case you used any technique then I would recommend you to create a new page with new content and scrap this page.
SEO Analysis 2 :
Search engines only allow 2 results from any single website. Therefore it could be possible that search engine picked up your other two pages and this page might have never got penalised. Search engines love fresh content and they simply replaced your old page with new page whenever you search for "military gifts and awards". If you search this keyword you will see your 2 links on pages 3-4.
SEO Suggestions to improve your rankings :
1) Add some plenty of useful content related to your targeted page.
2) You have gone overboard in the "KEYWORDS" tag. I would prefer to use a maximum of 3-5 keywords.
3) Add your description tag in a natural english targeting your keyword, and not keyword stuffed english.
3) Remove on-page javascript and style sheet. Use external style sheets
4) Your Google page rank is not related to your website's actual rankings on Google. Try not to concentrate your entire efforts on Page Rank.
5) ("Military Creed, Soldiers Creed, Airman's Creed, Sailor's Creed") is not a keyword in terms of
SEO. It is just a long sentence which has an extremely low probability of getting searched on any search engine. I would say the probability is somewhere in between -0.05% to -0.10
In case you are not able to recover this page ( in case you used some controversial
SEO technique), then I would recommend you to create a new page with fresh content and it will surely pick up rankings fast.
Also add a link to your newly created page from the home page itself
WISHING YOUR WEB PAGE A SPEEDY RECOVERY