I agree RE pop-ups - I use a blocker, and if by some voodoo a site manages to get past it, my blood pressure rises, I curse and head for the x button, never to return.

Personally, I would use an opt in form in a prime location on your page - people see it, and if they want to join your site they will. If they don't, a pop-up will not change their mind.

__________________
Free Membership - Resell Rights, Private Label Rights, Internet Marketing Videos & Tools.