Fathom, you are wasting your time, really. check out the signature of people here:
1) AVC: link to a forum with only a handful of suscribers
2) cranky Dave: links to a blog where comments come only from SPAM bots
3) etc ..
And they are talking like
SEO experts..
I suspect that we are actually not talking to real people, but to sophisticated SPAM bots, who are spamming forums such as WPW with nonsense:
Objective: get real people to post sensible answers, and make the threads look genuine.