View Single Post
  #102 (permalink)  
Old 03-26-2008, 01:32 AM
Peter (IMC)'s Avatar
Peter (IMC) Peter (IMC) is offline
WebProWorld MVP
WebProWorld MVP
 
Join Date: Dec 2003
Posts: 1,485
Peter (IMC) RepRank 4Peter (IMC) RepRank 4Peter (IMC) RepRank 4Peter (IMC) RepRank 4
Default Re: Does PR Sculpting Work?

Quote:
And, you don't get to keep and count the PR that you have to pass to others; i.e., you don't get to vote for yourself.
You do get to vote for yourself, but not through links themselves. More pages in your site will add PR to your site. (but 10 pages more isn't going to make much diference. This difference is only noticable when comparing sites with few pages to sites with tens of thousands of pages.)

PR sculpting is possible with nofollow, (but it's a waste of time as far as I'm concerned.) I agree with the way Janeth describes how PR works. Every page has a single PR point (not toolbar PR point but real PR point) to start with (before calculating the distribution of PR) and thus the total amount of PR available in Google's index is at most the number of pages they have indexed. Then after an iterative process the distribution of PR through links is determined.

So that answers the question: "But, how is the initial value created?"


There is no "proof" needed to determine wether or not PR sculpting with the nofollow works or not. It does work because if you deny a link to pass PR then the distribution will be different. The more important question is whether or not this has any significant effect on positions and traffic to your website. In my opinion it has very little effect simply because PR is just one of the many ranking factors and what's more important, the amount of PR you can channel away from certain pages to other pages is so small that you´re talking about a change in real PR of less than a %.

In case you have a really big site of tens of thousands of pages (which is actually what Greg Boser is talking about, Webnauts) then you can significantly sculpt PR in the site. And I can imagine that in those specific cases it can have a positive effect on positions for some keywords. But I have to say that I suspect that there is also a negative effect on the number of keywords the site is found for which in turn means less traffic to the site. Which brings me back to my original point that using nofollow to sculpt PR is a waste of time.
__________________
FREE SEO ! Really? YES! All you have to do is implement it!
Follow me on Twitter PeterIMC

Last edited by Peter (IMC); 03-26-2008 at 01:34 AM.
Reply With Quote