Dave, Index.asp is a great point. Thanks. That could be it...

Once again, my point with starting this thread was not trying to figure out what I did wrong (which actually I am thanks to your great comments) but on a higher level express my frastruation with Google's lack of customer service to all of us: site owners, biz owners, webmasters. Yes they have the tools and online accounts but why can not we call a number and ask why am I being penalized from your search engine and they say because you forgot your index.asp as a second home page. And I go yes, thank you. Will fix it.

I think assuming that Google has only responsibility to its Shareholders and nobody else, is the same mentality that says: Ok if Enron steals from its shareholders its bad, but if Enron gauges the price for consumers, or tries to trick small business to make more money it is ok.

Anyway, too much philosophy I guess. But again here is my question again.

How many legitimate online businesses you think Google killed in the past because those businesses did not know where to ask the question "why I am being penalized"? and Dave said "look at your index.asp".