craig...pointing the new domain to the current content and implementing redirects will not result in a loss of traffic...i know this from specific experience on a large scale site.

building a new site will take far greater time and effort than you are outlining and is probably not a realistic option for most clients.

by leaving the old domain live, but redirecting the current content will be updated in all major engines much more quickly than the solution you are suggesting

__________________
We offer a total eCommerce solution with eCommerce Web Design using Pinnacle Cart