Dave, I liked your review. Short, sweet, to the point.

But here are my thoughts on the logo. You've got something to work with here. Perhaps give it to your design company as your "concept" and see if they can apply a professional touch to it.

Or:

1. Clean up the quality of the image. It got very messy and blotchy when you flattened it out.
2. Your choice of font for the "Your Ad Tracker" phrase and the "Secure Your Free Membership Now" at the bottom of the page is highly unprofessional. It looks more like a hybrid of the rock bands KISS's and AC/DC's signature fonts. Is this the message you're trying to send to your customers?
3. The logo itself is jagged on the edges. Think clean. Think smooth.
4. And finally, why are you using black and red as your colors? Is there a reason for it? A lot of theories exist about how color schemes convey a message about your organization or business. I have my opinions on what black and red create in my mind, but you should do your own research and form your own opinions.

Good luck with your project!