1 - There are many errors that need to be fixed. Use the W3C validator:
http://validator.w3.org/check?uri=http://pebblez.com

You jumped your error count from 7 to 36.

2 - Trim your spaces. You got text that is broken by linebreaks all over the place, that in your original page where ok. I.E:
"Rustic
Stone Home Decor"
Instead of:
"Rustic Stone Home Decor"

Basically you are losing a lot of keywords because of that, for you won't rank anymore for "rustic stone", "rustic stone home", or any derivatives. The same happens all over the place!

---------
Fix those 2 points (which is fairly simple to do BTW), and wait for the next reindexation. You should do a lot better... good luck ;)