Have you checked to see if the old domain has been indexed yet, with the new content? If you do a search for site:bodyjewelryshopping.com on Google, MSN, and Yahoo, you'll see which pages have been indexed. If the content is from the new site, then you're safe.

Also, did you use the same page names on the old domain for the new site? If not, then you can do a 301 permanent redirect from each old page to the corresponding page under the new domain.