Originally Posted by AvgJoe

But this allinanchor thing is interesting.

If we rank tops for allinanchor:keywords, this means we have done well in gathering IBLs with our anchor text. But we still don't do well for natural search.

So, something else is going on, any bright ideas?

pne has suggested something to do with dynamic sites - well mine is, so that may be a lead - does it only happen to dynamic sites?